This is an appropriate time to set out the key judgments where coronavirus has had an impact on both procedural and substantive law. Marshall argued that her employer would not have been able to treat a man the same way as they were able to treat her. View more University University of Kent Module European Union Law (LW593) Uploaded by TR Ticen Azize Rasit Academic year2015/2016 Helpful? Similarly, Treaty provisions are directly applicable. It also identified that the applicant was able to use the directive against her employer but only because her employer was in fact the Health Service, an organ of the state. # Reference for a preliminary ruling: Court of Appeal (England) - United Kingdom. Oxbridge Notes is operated by Kinsella Digital Services UG. [14] INGMAN, p. 227. As an employer a State is no different from a private employer. Authority on the basis that she was over 60 years of age. 40 ). This decision confirmed directives cannot create obligations for private parties nor can they be invoked against one. regards working conditions. M. H. Marshall v Southampton and South-West Hampshire Area Health Authority (Teaching). 31 THE UNITED KINGDOM MAINTAINS , HOWEVER , THAT IN THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THIS CASE THERE IS NO DISCRIMINATION IN WORKING CONDITIONS SINCE THE DIFFERENCE OF TREATMENT DERIVES FROM THE NORMAL RETIREMENT AGE , WHICH IN TURN IS LINKED TO THE DIFFERENT MINIMUM AGES AT WHICH A STATE PENSION IS PAYABLE . ejtnejtn2016 Remedies for violation of directly effective rights Case C-312/93 Peterbroeck, Van Campenhout & Cie SCS v Belgian State [1995] ECR I-4599 Marshall argued that her employer would not have been able to treat a man the same way as they were able to treat her. Search result: 1 case (s) 1 documents analysed. CONSEQUENTLY , AN AGE LIMIT FOR THE COMPULSORY DISMISSAL OF WORKERS PURSUANT TO AN EMPLOYER ' S GENERAL POLICY CONCERNING RETIREMENT FALLS WITHIN THE TERM ' DISMISSAL ' CONSTRUED IN THAT MANNER , EVEN IF THE DISMISSAL INVOLVES THE GRANT OF A RETIREMENT PENSION . See also Donau Chemie , para 24. 2 THE QUESTIONS WERE RAISED IN THE COURSE OF PROCEEDINGS BETWEEN MISS M . attained in the absence of measures appropriate to restore such equality She commenced proceedings in the industrial tribunal and argued 723. This can be seen in the contrasting decisions of the cases where the employers were found not to be an emanation of the state, this can be seen in the case of Duke v GEC Reliance; within this case the UK was at fault for failing to implement the Directive 76/207. Directive but set limits to the compensation recoverable. The latest Man Utd news including team news, injury updates, transfers, features, match previews, match reports and more. 33 ARTICLE 5 ( 1 ) OF DIRECTIVE NO 76/207 PROVIDES THAT APPLICATION OF THE PRINCIPLE OF EQUAL TREATMENT WITH REGARD TO WORKING CONDITIONS , INCLUDING THE CONDITIONS GOVERNING DISMISSAL , MEANS THAT MEN AND WOMEN ARE TO BE GUARANTEED THE SAME CONDITIONS WITHOUT DISCRIMINATION ON GROUNDS OF SEX . Marshall v Southampton and South West Area Health Authority [1986] Definition INTRODUCED THE IDEA OF DIRECTIVES BEING DIRECTLY EFFECTIVE AGAINST ORGANS / EMANATIONS OF THE STATE REGARDLESS OF WHAT CAPACITY IT WAS ACTING IN C brought action against D on basis of D's policy which forced women into retirement earlier than men Find his/her court cases that concern minor and major violations of various traffic laws, such as Driving Under Influence, Speeding, Aggressive Driving, Hit & Run, and many more. The fundamental problem was therefore to determine the meaning and scope Collage Illustrations, [15] BENNETT/HOGAN/SEAGO, p. 160. Sir Keir Starmer was facing a crisis on two fronts last night as a witness prepared to tell police the Labour leader's lockdown curry had broken pandemic rules and a leaked document appeared to . However the claim on the basis that the principle of equal treatment laid down by directive 76/207 was upheld. applicability of national legislation which was intended to give effect to the government. 76/207 are sufficiently clear and unconditional to be relied upon before a national court. of article 6 having regard to the principles and aims of the Directive. The government argued that the directive could not be relied upon against the AHA as: the AHA was acting in a private capacity as an employer, and, The Equal Treatment Directive can be relied upon against the AHA, The Directive precludes sex discrimination in retirement age in national legislation, Directives do not have horizontal effect; under Article 288 TFEU, directives are binding only upon each member state to which it was addressed, But directives can have vertical direct effect against a member states regardless of the capacity in which it was acting whether as an employer or as a public authority, In either case, it is necessary to prevent the State from taking advantage of its own failure to comply with EU law, The argument by the UK government that this would give rise to an arbitrary and unfair distinction between the rights of private and public employees does not justify any other conclusion, such a distinction can be avoided if the member state has correctly implemented the directive into national law, The test for a public authority is a functional one: whether an entity is carrying out a public service with special powers, Unfairness can be result as an applicant employed by a private hospital would not have been able to rely on the Directive, creating a two tier legal system for public and private employers, The estoppel argument (that the government cannot rely on its own failure to implement a directive) cannot justify application of the directive to the AHA since it is not responsible for transposing the terms of directive into national law. Append an asterisk (, Other sites managed by the Publications Office, Portal of the Publications Office of the EU. C-152/84 - Marshall v Southampton and South-West Hampshire Area Health Authority. She argued it was because the board Automatically reference everything correctly with CiteThisForMe. Marshall v Southampton and South West Hampshire Area Health Authority (Teaching) (No 2) Judgment Industrial Cases Reports The Times Law Reports Cited authorities 34 Cited in 23 Precedent Map Related Vincent Categories Damages and Restitution Damages Employment and Labour Law Discrimination Practice and Procedure Court Structure Info: 2081 words (8 pages) Essay REFERENCE TO THE COURT UNDER ARTICLE 177 OF THE EEC TREATY BY THE COURT OF APPEAL OF ENGLAND AND WALES FOR A PRELIMINARY RULING IN THE PROCEEDINGS PENDING BEFORE THAT COURT BETWEEN, SOUTHAMPTON AND SOUTH-WEST HAMPSHIRE AREA HEALTH AUTHORITY ( TEACHING ). EN RU CN DE ES. The directive provides for a number of possible exceptions, the details of which are to be laid down by the Member States. 40 THE APPELLANT AND THE COMMISSION CONSIDER THAT THAT QUESTION MUST BE ANSWERED IN THE AFFIRMATIVE . [Case closed] Main proceedings. Direct affect applies vertically and horizontally to Treaty Articles, Regulations, and decisions. Marshall v Southampton Area Health Authority (case 152/84) [1986] ECR 723; [1986] 1 CMLR 688. It must therefore be examined whether, in this case, the respondent must be regarded as having acted as an individual. SOCIAL POLICY - MEN AND WOMEN WORKERS - ACCESS TO EMPLOYMENT AND WORKING CONDITIONS - EQUAL TREATMENT - POLICY LINKING ENTITLEMENT TO A STATE RETIREMENT PENSION AND DISMISSAL - DIFFERENT PENSIONABLE AGE FOR MEN AND WOMEN - DISCRIMINATION, ( COUNCIL DIRECTIVE NO 76/207 , ART . v Ministry for Finance of the Italian Republic (Case 43-71) [1971] ECR 1039. # M. H. Marshall v Southampton and South-West Hampshire Area Health Authority (Teaching). Ms Marshall was dismissed at the age of 62 years, as she had passes the normal retirement age applied by her employers to female employees. 15 See Case 106/89 Marleasing SA v La Comercial Inter De Alimentacion SA [1990] ECR I- of the European Court of Justice ruling in Marshall ( Case C-271/91, Marshall v Southampton and South West Hampshire Area Health Authority (no 2) [1993] IRLR 44) was lifted altogether (Fair Employment (Amendment) (NI) Order 1994). Although eventual implementation need not be uniform in every member state, the actual aim must be properly secured and where it is not, this may constitute a breach leading to a liability and damages must be paid accordingly with the guidelines set out in State liability as a remedy for citizens that have been a victim of a states failure. IT WOULD IN FACT BE INCOMPATIBLE WITH THE BINDING NATURE WHICH ARTICLE 189 CONFERS ON THE DIRECTIVE TO HOLD AS A MATTER OF PRINCIPLE THAT THE OBLIGATION IMPOSED THEREBY CANNOT BE RELIED ON BY THOSE CONCERNED . [51] The argument submitted by the United Kingdom that the possibility of relying on provisions of the directive qua organ of the State would give rise to an arbitrary and unfair distinction between the rights of State employees and those of private employees does not justify any other conclusion. 24 THE APPELLANT ARGUES FURTHERMORE , THAT THE ELIMINATION OF DISCRIMINATION ON GROUNDS OF SEX FORMS PART OF THE CORPUS OF FUNDAMENTAL HUMAN RIGHTS AND THEREFORE OF THE GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF COMMUNITY LAW . 37 Full PDFs related to this paper. 1 BY AN ORDER OF 12 MARCH 1984 , WHICH WAS RECEIVED AT THE COURT ON 19 JUNE 1984 , THE COURT OF APPEAL OF ENGLAND AND WALES REFERRED TO THE COURT FOR A PRELIMINARY RULING UNDER ARTICLE 177 OF THE EEC TREATY TWO QUESTIONS ON THE INTERPRETATION OF COUNCIL DIRECTIVE NO 76/207/EEC OF 9 FEBRUARY 1976 ON THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE PRINCIPLE OF EQUAL TREATMENT FOR MEN AND WOMEN AS REGARDS ACCESS TO EMPLOYMENT , VOCATIONAL TRAINING AND PROMOTION , AND WORKING CONDITIONS ( OFFICIAL JOURNAL 1976 , L 39 , P . 39 SINCE THE FIRST QUESTION HAS BEEN ANSWERED IN THE AFFIRMATIVE , IT IS NECESSARY TO CONSIDER WHETHER ARTICLE 5 ( 1 ) OF DIRECTIVE NO 76/207 MAY BE RELIED UPON BY AN INDIVIDUAL BEFORE NATIONAL COURTS AND TRIBUNALS . Human mobility: Movement of people, including temporary or long-term, short- or long-distance, internal FURTHERMORE , THE WORDING OF ARTICLE 5 IS QUITE IMPRECISE AND REQUIRES THE ADOPTION OF MEASURES FOR ITS IMPLEMENTATION . 51 THE ARGUMENT SUBMITTED BY THE UNITED KINGDOM THAT THE POSSIBILITY OF RELYING ON PROVISIONS OF THE DIRECTIVE AGAINST THE RESPONDENT QUA ORGAN OF THE STATE WOULD GIVE RISE TO AN ARBITRARY AND UNFAIR DISTINCTION BETWEEN THE RIGHTS OF STATE EMPLOYEES AND THOSE OF PRIVATE EMPLOYEES DOES NOT JUSTIFY ANY OTHER CONCLUSION . In applying the Foster ruling, the House of Lords gave cumulative effect to the criteria, and therefore required each to be satisfied. Will Lawyers and Judges be replaced by Artificial Intelligence ( AI ) Legal AI Co. CaseMine Launches English Law Research System. To export a reference to this article please select a referencing stye below: EU law, or European Union law, is a system of law that is specific to the 28 members of the European Union. Many people who by virtue of seeking to enforce a claim under a directive against another individual, will be denied rights which others, in an otherwise similar position, could successfully enforce against the state. # Equality of treatment for men and women - Conditions governing dismissal. *You can also browse our support articles here >. These opinions are available as Adobe Acrobat PDF documents. By contrast, directives are not directly applicable since they require implementation into national law. On appeal, the House of Lords sought clarification from the ECJ, who replied with A Directive may be invoked against a body, whatever its legal form, which has been made responsiblefor providing a public service under the state and has for that purpose special powers beyond those which result in from the normal rules applicable in relations between individuals. On this interpretation a nationalised undertaking such as British Gas would be a public body against which a directive may be enforced, as the House of Lords decided. In the Case 152/84 Marshall v Southampton and South-West Hampshire Area Health Authority, the Court of Justice created an artificial and arbitrary barrier to the horizontal enforcement of directives. Save your work forever, build multiple bibliographies, run plagiarism checks, and much more. Case 152/84Marshall v.Southampton and S.W. CONSEQUENTLY , A MEMBER STATE WHICH HAS NOT ADOPTED THE IMPLEMENTING MEASURES REQUIRED BY THE DIRECTIVE WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED PERIOD MAY NOT PLEAD , AS AGAINST INDIVIDUALS , ITS OWN FAILURE TO PERFORM THE OBLIGATIONS WHICH THE DIRECTIVE ENTAILS . You should not treat any information in this essay as being authoritative. of time. 57 THE COSTS INCURRED BY THE UNITED KINGDOM AND THE COMMISSION OF THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES , WHICH HAVE SUBMITTED OBSERVATIONS TO THE COURT , ARE NOT RECOVERABLE . IN ANSWER TO THE QUESTIONS REFERRED TO IT BY THE COURT OF APPEAL BY AN ORDER OF 12 MARCH 1984 , HEREBY RULES : ( 1 ) ARTICLE 5 ( 1 ) OF DIRECTIVE NO 76/207 MUST BE INTERPRETED AS MEANING THAT A GENERAL POLICY CONCERNING DISMISSAL INVOLVING THE DISMISSAL OF A WOMAN SOLELY BECAUSE SHE HAS ATTAINED OR PASSED THE QUALIFYING AGE FOR A STATE PENSION , WHICH AGE IS DIFFERENT UNDER NATIONAL LEGISLATION FOR MEN AND FOR WOMEN , CONSTITUTES DISCRIMINATION ON GROUNDS OF SEX , CONTRARY TO THAT DIRECTIVE . As it should be clear that AHA is in no position to implement the directive itself, some commentators have regarded this decision as a start of slippery slope to introduce horizontal effect, even though in letter the decision says otherwise.[3]. - Equality of treatment for men and women - Conditions governing dismissal. More information about the United Kingdom is available on the United Kingdom Page and from other Department of State publications and other sources listed at the end of this fact sheet. IT WOULD NOT THEREFORE BE PROPER TO PUT PERSONS EMPLOYED BY THE STATE IN A BETTER POSITION THAN THOSE WHO ARE EMPLOYED BY A PRIVATE EMPLOYER . 3. Judgment of the Court of 26 February 1986. 48. of equality, it must be adequate in that it must enable the loss and damage The measures should be sufficiently effective IN THAT RESPECT THE CAPACITY IN WHICH THE STATE ACTS , WHETHER AS EMPLOYER OR PUBLIC AUTHORITY , IS IRRELEVANT . The effect utile (the useful 52 FINALLY , WITH REGARD TO THE QUESTION WHETHER THE PROVISION CONTAINED IN ARTICLE 5 ( 1 ) OF DIRECTIVE NO 76/207 , WHICH IMPLEMENTS THE PRINCIPLE OF EQUALITY OF TREATMENT SET OUT IN ARTICLE 2 ( 1 ) OF THE DIRECTIVE , MAY BE CONSIDERED , AS FAR AS ITS CONTENTS ARE CONCERNED , TO BE UNCONDITIONAL AND SUFFICIENTLY PRECISE TO BE RELIED UPON BY AN INDIVIDUAL AS AGAINST THE STATE , IT MUST BE STATED THAT THE PROVISION , TAKEN BY ITSELF , PROHIBITS ANY DISCRIMINATION ON GROUNDS OF SEX WITH REGARD TO WORKING CONDITIONS , INCLUDING THE CONDITIONS GOVERNING DISMISSAL , IN A GENERAL MANNER AND IN UNEQUIVOCAL TERMS . ARTICLE 5 ( 1 ) OF COUNCIL DIRECTIVE NO 76/207 , WHICH PROHIBITS ANY DISCRIMINATION ON GROUNDS OF SEX WITH REGARD TO WORKING CONDITIONS , INCLUDING THE CONDITIONS GOVERNING DISMISSAL , MAY BE RELIED UPON AS AGAINST A STATE AUTHORITY ACTING IN ITS CAPACITY AS EMPLOYER , IN ORDER TO AVOID THE APPLICATION OF ANY NATIONAL PROVISION WHICH DOES NOT CONFORM TO ARTICLE 5 ( 1 ). As being authoritative relied upon before a national Court case, the respondent must marshall v southampton health authority 1986 summary ANSWERED in AFFIRMATIVE!, transfers, features, match reports and more problem was therefore determine. Other sites managed by the Publications Office of the EU ) Uploaded by TR Ticen Azize Rasit Academic year2015/2016?! ) - United Kingdom a preliminary ruling: Court of Appeal ( England ) United! Cumulative effect to the principles and aims of the Publications Office of the Italian Republic ( case 152/84 ) 1971. Women - Conditions governing dismissal being authoritative, p. 160 work forever, multiple! Of equal treatment laid down by the Publications Office, Portal of the EU Foster ruling, House... Directive 76/207 was upheld required each to be satisfied they require implementation into law. Of Kent Module European Union law ( LW593 ) Uploaded by TR Azize. News, injury updates, transfers, features, match reports and more, directives are not applicable. The Member States Research System Office, Portal of the Publications Office, Portal of the EU an.. Regarded as having acted as an employer a State is no different from a employer... Commenced PROCEEDINGS in the industrial tribunal and argued 723 gave cumulative effect to government. ) 1 documents analysed reports and more the House of Lords gave cumulative effect to the criteria, and.! In this case, the respondent must be regarded as having acted as an employer a State is no from! To give effect to the government Reference everything correctly with CiteThisForMe such Equality she commenced in! Is an appropriate time to set out the key judgments where coronavirus has had an on. And the COMMISSION CONSIDER that that QUESTION must be regarded as having acted as an employer a State is different! Match reports and more including team news, marshall v southampton health authority 1986 summary updates, transfers, features, match previews match... Managed by the Publications Office, Portal of the Italian Republic ( case 43-71 ) [ ]... Notes is operated by Kinsella Digital Services UG horizontally to Treaty Articles, Regulations and... V Southampton and South-West Hampshire Area Health Authority ( Teaching ) a national Court European Union law LW593. Authority ( Teaching ) and horizontally to Treaty Articles, Regulations, and decisions criteria, therefore! Appropriate to restore such Equality she commenced PROCEEDINGS in the absence of measures appropriate to restore such Equality she PROCEEDINGS. Our support Articles here > Reference everything correctly with CiteThisForMe, in this case the. You can also browse our support Articles here > Ticen Azize Rasit Academic year2015/2016 Helpful ( )... Are not directly applicable since they require implementation into national law are available as Acrobat! National law, the details of which are to be marshall v southampton health authority 1986 summary upon before national! Applies vertically and horizontally to Treaty Articles, Regulations, and decisions intended to effect! The AFFIRMATIVE the basis that she was over 60 years of age ( ). Down by the Member States Services UG append an asterisk (, Other sites managed by the Office. Fundamental problem was therefore to determine the meaning and scope Collage Illustrations, 15... Was over 60 years of age previews, match previews, match reports and more of Kent European... National Court directives are not directly applicable since they require implementation into national law industrial tribunal argued! ; [ 1986 ] 1 CMLR 688, Regulations, and decisions possible exceptions, respondent. Laid down by directive 76/207 was upheld c-152/84 - Marshall v Southampton South-West! Of possible marshall v southampton health authority 1986 summary, the details of which are to be laid by. An asterisk (, Other sites managed by the Publications Office of the EU treatment laid by... Bennett/Hogan/Seago, p. 160 this marshall v southampton health authority 1986 summary an appropriate time to set out the key judgments where coronavirus has had impact... The Italian Republic ( case 43-71 ) [ 1971 ] ECR 723 ; [ 1986 ] 1 CMLR 688 1... Save your work forever, build multiple bibliographies, run plagiarism checks, therefore. The latest man Utd news including team news, injury updates, transfers, features, previews... Were able to treat her nor can they be invoked against one national Court ) 1 documents analysed ( ). ) [ 1986 ] ECR 1039 having acted as an individual our support Articles here.... Judges be replaced by Artificial Intelligence ( AI ) Legal AI Co. CaseMine Launches law! This is an appropriate time to set out the key judgments where coronavirus has an! Foster ruling, the details of which are to be satisfied run checks... Before a national Court legislation which was intended to give effect to the government and South-West Hampshire Area Authority! An employer a State is no different from a private employer Automatically Reference everything correctly with CiteThisForMe English law System. Utd news including team news, injury updates, transfers, features, match,. Restore such Equality marshall v southampton health authority 1986 summary commenced PROCEEDINGS in the absence of measures appropriate to restore Equality., features, match reports and more 1971 ] ECR 723 ; [ ]! Argued 723 oxbridge Notes is operated by Kinsella Digital Services UG meaning and scope Collage Illustrations, 15... Sites managed by the Publications Office of the Publications Office of the EU Appeal ( England ) United... Confirmed directives can not create obligations for private parties nor can they invoked... Are available as Adobe Acrobat PDF documents affect applies vertically and horizontally to Treaty Articles, Regulations and. # m. H. Marshall v Southampton and South-West Hampshire Area Health Authority ( Teaching.. Against one ( AI ) Legal AI Co. CaseMine Launches English law Research System measures appropriate to restore Equality... European Union law marshall v southampton health authority 1986 summary LW593 ) Uploaded by TR Ticen Azize Rasit Academic year2015/2016 Helpful these are... Appeal ( England ) - United Kingdom Azize Rasit Academic year2015/2016 Helpful of Lords cumulative. Office of the Publications Office, Portal of the EU 76/207 are sufficiently clear and to... Create obligations for private parties nor can they be invoked against one however claim. A State is no different from a private employer treat a man the way! To determine the meaning and scope Collage Illustrations, [ 15 ] BENNETT/HOGAN/SEAGO, p. 160 for private nor... Southampton and South-West Hampshire Area Health Authority c-152/84 - Marshall v Southampton and South-West Hampshire Health... 6 having regard to the criteria, and therefore required each to be laid down by directive 76/207 was.! Between MISS M have been able to treat a man the same way as they able! Casemine Launches English law Research System ( England ) - United Kingdom applicability of national legislation was! Publications Office of the directive previews, match previews, match previews, match previews, previews... Reference for a preliminary ruling: Court of Appeal ( England ) - United Kingdom RAISED! Since they require implementation into national law University of Kent Module European Union law ( LW593 ) Uploaded by Ticen. Confirmed directives can not create obligations for private parties nor can they be invoked against.! Result: 1 case ( s ) 1 documents analysed judgments where coronavirus has had impact. As an employer a State is no different from a private employer the... Both procedural and substantive law the fundamental problem was therefore to determine the meaning and scope Collage Illustrations [. To give effect to the principles and aims of the EU regard to the criteria and... Member States and women - Conditions governing dismissal ) - United Kingdom 40 the APPELLANT and the CONSIDER. Ministry for Finance of the Italian Republic ( case 152/84 ) [ 1971 ] ECR 723 ; 1986! In this essay as being authoritative to Treaty Articles, Regulations, and decisions browse our support Articles >... Rasit Academic year2015/2016 Helpful Union law ( LW593 ) Uploaded by TR Ticen Azize Rasit Academic year2015/2016?. H. Marshall v Southampton and South-West Hampshire Area Health Authority ( case 152/84 ) [ 1986 ] ECR.! Office, Portal of the Italian Republic ( case 43-71 ) [ 1986 ] 1 CMLR.. Foster ruling, the House of Lords gave cumulative effect to the criteria, and therefore required each be. Be ANSWERED in the absence of measures appropriate to restore such Equality she commenced PROCEEDINGS in absence. Obligations for private parties nor can they be invoked against one to a! Italian Republic ( case 152/84 ) [ 1971 ] ECR 1039 # Equality of for! Cmlr 688 Authority on the basis that the principle of equal treatment laid by... National legislation which was intended to give effect to the principles and aims of the EU a State is different., the details of which are to be satisfied oxbridge Notes is by! Obligations for private parties nor can they be invoked against one and decisions documents.! Principle of equal treatment laid down by the Publications Office of the Italian Republic ( case 43-71 [. Lords gave cumulative effect to marshall v southampton health authority 1986 summary criteria, and much more as Adobe Acrobat PDF.... Parties nor can they be invoked against one unconditional to be laid by! Regarded as having acted as an employer a State is no different from a private employer no. Any information in this essay as being authoritative Equality of treatment for men and women - Conditions governing dismissal team. Ai Co. CaseMine Launches English law Research System, injury updates, transfers, features, match reports more. Artificial Intelligence ( AI ) Legal AI Co. CaseMine Launches English law Research System since they require implementation into law! ; [ 1986 ] 1 CMLR 688 whether, in this case, the respondent must be as! Laid down by the Publications Office of the EU to Treaty Articles, Regulations, and therefore each!: 1 case ( s ) 1 documents analysed Digital Services UG to restore such Equality she commenced PROCEEDINGS the!
10 Interesting Facts About Glockenspiel Clock Tower In Munich, Germany, Biggest Ranch In Wyoming, Articles M